When The Rookie premiered in 2018, Nathan Fillion was the show’s main attraction, stepping into the unique role of John Nolan—a 40-year-old contractor who, after stopping an armed robbery at his local bank, decides to make a bold career change by joining the police academy. Initially, the series focused heavily on Nolan’s late-life entry into law enforcement, with the supporting cast primarily existing to enhance his story. However, fast forward to Season 6, and The Rookie has evolved into a true ensemble drama. With 100 episodes under its belt, every character now stands out in their own right, proving there are endless stories to explore beyond Nolan’s journey.

Season 6, Episode 2, “The Hammer,” brings a wave of nostalgia for long-time fans of the series. While the episode isn’t without its missed opportunities—like the absence of Pete Davidson, who likely couldn’t make an appearance—there’s only so much that can be packed into a 40-minute episode. Despite these limitations, this character-driven installment manages to captivate from start to finish, blending humor, drama, and heartfelt moments in a way that pays homage to the best aspects of the show.

Honoring the Core of The Rookie: Heart, Humor, and High Stakes

From the moment “Daddy Cop” played in the cold open, it was clear that “The Hammer” would lean into the show’s comedic roots. The clever choice to send Randy as Chastity’s date in place of Pete was a fun way to keep the spirit alive and allowed more beloved characters to join in on the festivities. Though Abigail’s absence was felt, bringing back Henry for the first time since Season 4 made the episode feel like a heartfelt family reunion.

The Rookie has always excelled at balancing its tone—making viewers laugh one moment and gasp in fear for a character’s life the next. Although the “ruined wedding” trope is a well-worn one in television, Nolan and Bailey’s series of mix-ups offered a fresh, entertaining spin. It also gave Grey a chance to step into the role of Nolan’s wedding officiant, showcasing just how far their relationship has developed since the sergeant’s initial wariness of Nolan’s unconventional path.

The episode also dives into more serious territory when Aaron attempts to kiss Celina, only to face a painful rejection. Nyla points out that Aaron’s actions stem from his need for support after being shot, but it remains unclear whether his feelings for Celina go beyond friendship. This awkward moment is crucial, as it forces the show to address the lingering tension between them. Celina’s decision to flee the wedding and end up in danger sets the stage for a classic Rookie rescue mission that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats until the very end.

A Deeper Look at The Rookie’s Central Relationships

While Nolan and Bailey’s wedding is the focal point of the episode, it’s clear that the most compelling romance isn’t the one at the altar—at least not yet. The Rookie’s strength lies in its rich, multidimensional cast, and the wedding reception offers a rare chance for each character to pause and reflect on their lives and past traumas. Nolan and Bailey’s touching vows provide a beautiful moment, but it’s Tim and Lucy who truly steal the show as the series’ most developed and beloved couple.

From the early days of the series, Tim and Lucy have been the emotional core of The Rookie, both individually and as partners. This dynamic only grew stronger with each passing season, culminating in their official pairing in Season 5. The 100th episode cleverly addresses the tension in their relationship—largely due to Lucy’s undercover work—and delivers a love confession that has been six years in the making.

Tim and Lucy’s conversation is a powerful reminder that their struggles are rooted in a deep love and concern for each other. While their worries may sometimes manifest as frustration, there is no hostility in their conflict—just the complexities of two people who care deeply. With Tim’s concerns now out in the open, it feels like the couple can finally move forward together, working through their fears as a team. The episode’s final moments, with Tim getting down on one knee, hint at an exciting future for the pair and signal a new era for the series.

A Perfect Tribute to Fans and a Fresh Start for the Series

“The Hammer” skillfully brings closure to several ongoing storylines while setting the stage for a new chapter in ABC’s beloved police procedural. The episode serves as a testament to the talented writers and the passionate fan base that has supported the series since the beginning. For a 100th episode, The Rookie delivers everything fans could hope for—humor, heart, and a promise of more thrilling stories to come.