90 Day Fiancé: I’m Certain Jenn Potthast Is Not Josh Weinstein’s Secret Cast Member Girlfriend (The Final Tell All Reveal Will Shock Fans)

90 Day: The Last Resort fans think that Josh Weinstein is dating Elizabeth Potthast’s sister, Jenn Potthast, but I don’t think that’s the case. Josh was first seen in 90 Day: The Single Life season 2. Natalie Mordovsteva had just moved to Florida after separating from Mike Youngquist and was dating a model named Johnny. The man took Natalie to a modeling workshop organized by Preview Models,a company owned by Josh. Natalie got acquainted with Josh at the event and went on a golfing date with him following her split with Johnny.

Natalie learned early on that Josh had two kids from two different relationships and wasn’t interested in having another baby. It had always been Natalie’s wish to become a mom, but I wonder why she decided to date Josh anyway. Josh also never showed commitment to Natalie as the two seemed to be in more of a situationship than a relationship that needed to be on a couples’ therapy spin-off. To my surprise, Josh and Natalie parted ways on the show but kept hooking up until Josh started dating someone new – a person who’s reportedly a cast member.

What Josh Revealed About His New Girlfriend

Josh’s Girlfriend Is From The 90 Day Fiancé Family

In a February episode of The Sarah Fraser Show podcast, Josh confirmed his split from Natalie. He claimed, “At the moment, I would say we are friends.” Josh called his relationship with Natalie a “wild ride” but admitted that he still cared for her. However, Josh and Natalie have both since moved on and have new partners. Josh revealed he was dating someone new from the 90 Day Fiancé universe. It looked like Josh may have gotten together with the co-star to film a future season of 90 Day: The Single Life.

Josh Will Introduce His New Girlfriend At The Tell All

Josh’s Girlfriend Is Someone The Cast Already Knows

90 Day Fiancé on Instagram has posted a trailer for the upcoming The Last Resort Tell All, which shares a bombshell revelation about Josh and Natalie. Host Shawn Robinson turns to Josh while filming and asks him if he has started to see anyone else. “Well, you know, I do like somebody. A lot. We’ve been hanging out a lot,” he admits. Shawn tells the cameras that they “actually” invited the new woman Josh has been seeing to the Tell All. “Some of you might recognize her already,” she adds and continues, “Please welcome…” leaving the audience and cast shocked.

Josh Has Been Photographed With His New Girlfriend

Who Is The Mystery Blonde? It Doesn’t Look Like Jenn

Shabooty posted pictures of Josh at the Las Vegas airport. Josh was flying to Phoenix. The 90 Day Fiancé blogger added that Josh was with a mystery woman. “It could be his new girlfriend,” he added. The blogger noted Josh was flying on American Airlines and was in “Group 1,” possibly meaning “first class.” Josh’s girlfriend also had a small dog with her.

“Yes, it’s his new GF!”

Sarah Fraser, who recently invited Josh on her podcast, The Sarah Fraser Show, left a surprising message for 90 Day Fiancé fans in the comments. She confirmed that the woman in the pictures was Josh’s new girlfriend. As per Sarah, Josh revealed on her podcast that he was dating someone new. As per Sarah, the woman will be appearing “at the tell alls” which suggests Josh will introduce his girlfriend on the 90 Day: The Last Resort season 2 Tell All.

Josh & Jenn’s Date Video Is Over Two Years Old

Did Josh & Jenn Even Date Or Were They Just Teasing Fans?

In March 2025, 90 Day Fiancé blogger 90dayfianceupdate shared a video suggesting that his 90 Day Fiancé mystery girlfriend may have been revealed. “Has he been hiding her for years?” the blogger asked. They explained that the woman in the video was Elizabeth’s sister Jenn, and asked fans if they remembered her. They explained Josh has known their family since Elizabeth’s mom runs a casting agency. The video showed Josh and Jenn next to each other at what looked like a fun night out. Josh had also tagged Jenn’s Instagram account in the clip.

Josh held a drink in his hand as he pointed at the camera with a goofy smile. Jenn, who was next to him, saw that he was filming and put her head on his shoulder. While Josh didn’t suggest it was a date night for them, they were surrounded by people at a noisy, loud place. Fans had a lot to say about Jenn in the comments. Some called her a major step up from Natalie. Someone assumed this meant Josh and Jenn would be together on a future spin-off.

Interestingly, the video was posted by Josh on his Instagram in February 2023. The video was shared by SignificantCamel8516 on Reddit. Back then, the fan asked others if Josh and Jenn were trolling them or if they were together. The fan concluded that it looked like Josh and Jenn were seeking attention.

Still, the two seemed more compatible than some fans think. Both Josh and Jenn have roots in Florida, which appears to be where they hung out. Jenn was living in Tampa with the rest of the Potthast family, and Josh met Natalie in Florida. Josh is supposed to have known the Potthast family through Jenn’s mom, Pamela Putnam. Both Josh and Jenn were single parents as well, and each had two kids, so it seemed that the two surprisingly had a lot in common. However, Josh got back together with Natalie after the video was posted.

Natalie Revealed Josh’s New Girlfriend Is Half His Age

Natalie More Or Less Confirms It’s Not Jenn

Natalie recently took to Instagram to share her thoughts on remarks Josh made about her. In a preview for the upcoming episode, Josh claimed Natalie called his ex-wife names and said that she was a “h**ker.” Josh admitted he got very emotional when Natalie came after his family. He also accused Natalie of being a liar and a “scam artist.” Hurt by what she was seeing on TV, Natalie wrote a long caption on Instagram claiming she never treated his ex-wife badly and that she was deeply hurt by him calling her a “liar” and a “scammer.”

“At the Tell All , he introduced a new girlfriend half his age.”

Natalie mentioned Josh’s new girlfriend in her statement. She wrote that Josh introduced his girlfriend at the 90 Day: The Last Resort Tell All and that she is half his age. Considering Natalie has been a part of the franchise long enough, she will be familiar with Jenn, who seems to be the same age as Josh and not half his age. Natalie’s remark about Josh’s new girlfriend does suggest that it is not Jenn that he is dating. However, the question remains who the mystery woman is then, considering the cast already knew about her when Josh brought her on stage.

90 Day: The Last Resort fans think that Josh Weinstein is dating Elizabeth Potthast’s sister, Jenn Potthast, but I don’t think that’s the case. Josh was first seen in 90 Day: The Single Life season 2. Natalie Mordovsteva had just moved to Florida after separating from Mike Youngquist and was dating a model named Johnny. The man took Natalie to a…