Amanda reveals to Will what she and her team have learned. The man with the handle in his back is Dale Sorenson, a known member of a biker gang who hires himself out as a hitman. The other man with the purse was Conrad Warren, a local youth pastor. Will reveals he’s learned the identity of the missing woman: Isabella Altman. Will surmises that someone lured Isabella to the mall, and paid Dale to kill her. However, he’s still not sure of Conrad’s role and so calls in his parents, who are accompanied by Pastor Reggie (Jerod Haynes), Conrad’s superior.

Every question Will asks Conrad’s parents is answered by Pastor Reggie, so Will removes Reggie to question him privately. Reggie insists Conrad was not involved and that he is not the father of Isabella’s baby. Will remains suspicious, distrusting religion in general, and goes to visit Reggie’s church, where Isabella was a member. There, he interviews the congregation and has a conversation with Reggie where Reggie tells Will that they both had pain in their youth. Despite his suspicions, Amanda traces Isabella’s parking pass to Councilman Carrie’s office, getting Reggie off the hook.

Faith and Will head to Carrie’s home where they meet him and his wife, Erin (Jennifer Westfeldt). GBI learns Isabella was an intern on Carrie’s campaign and Erin is distraught to learn that she’s disappeared. As Faith and Will leave their home, they both note how anxious Councilman Carrie was during their conversation.

The APD Visits Ted Burkle’s Brother And Goes To His Gym

Ted’s Brother Joel Isn’t Much Help In The Investigation

Back at the other investigation, the APD interviews Ted’s brother Joel Burkle (Will Rothhaar), who tearfully says he and Ted were supposed to have a day at the spa together for Ted’s birthday. They were only a few minutes in when Ted collapsed. Though Joel can’t think of anyone who would want Ted dead, he admits that his brother was generous but could be self-centered.

Their investigation inevitably takes them to the Ruby Dreams Wellness Center. Summer Fairfield (Cara Mantella), the owner of the spa, is questioned when APD learns Ted intended to start his own spa, but Summer claims she had no problem with that. Angie and Michael also question another gym member, Wolfgang (William McKinney), whom Ted was supposed to go into business with.

Wolfgang claims there were no hard feelings when Ted backed out, but the APD finds one of Wolfgang’s branded essential oils melting on a hot stone, suggesting he is destroying evidence. Despite declaring his innocence, Ange and Michael take him back to the department for more questioning.

Michael And Angie Realize Who Killed Ted Burkle

Wolfgang Gives The APD An Important Piece Of Information

Forensics reveals that the melted oil does indeed contain buprenorphine, incriminating Wolfgang, but he insists he’s innocent. He reveals that Ted stepped away from the business because his father was dying from cancer, something Joel failed to mention. Together they rush to the hospice care facility to find Joel sitting by his father’s bed. Surprised by their arrival, Joel begins telling the detectives how he’s been taking care of his father for two years. As he continues talking, it becomes apparent that Joel resents his brother for leaving him to care for his father alone.